MagraHearth
Natural Wood
Mantel Shelf · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
Finish Work & Accessories
Fireplace Mantels & Cabinets in Oneonta, NY
Finish the fireplace wall right. Browse wood mantels and shelves, non-combustible surrounds, natural stone, and fireplace cabinets from MagraHearth, Fireside Finishings, SimpliFire, and Mount Vernon Mantels—each one measured and installed by our in-house team.
More Than 30 Years in Central New York
NFI-Certified Technicians
5,000 Sq Ft Showroom
We Install What We Sell
Browse Fireplace Mantels & Cabinets
MagraHearth
Large Barn Beam
Beam · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Chiseled Stone
Mantel Shelf · Non-Combustible · Shown: Buff
4 Finishes
MagraHearth
Rustic Barn Wood
Mantel Shelf · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Natty XL
Mantel Shelf · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Norington
Mantel Shelf · Non-Combustible · Shown: Cocoa
4 Finishes
MagraHearth
Alder Box
Mantel Shelf · Non-Combustible · Shown: Cocoa
4 Finishes
MagraHearth
Mortise Barn Beam Series
Beam · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Small Mortise Post
Post · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Small Plain Post
Post · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Chiseled Stone Corbel
Corbel · Non-Combustible · Shown: Grey
4 Finishes
MagraHearth
Rustic Corbels
Corbel · Non-Combustible · Shown: WhiteWash
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Butt End Corbels
Corbel · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
MagraHearth
Post & Beam Surround
Surround · Non-Combustible · Shown: Brown
7 Finishes
Fireside Finishings
Kenwood Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel
Fireside Finishings
Laurel Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel
Fireside Finishings
Battlefield Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel · Knotty Alder or Primed MDF
Fireside Finishings
Roxborough Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel
Fireside Finishings
Wescott Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel · Primed MDF
Fireside Finishings
Richland Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel · Primed MDF
Fireside Finishings
Merritt Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel · Primed MDF and with or without corbels
Fireside Finishings
Zimmer Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel · Primed MDF
Fireside Finishings
Malone Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel · Primed MDF
Fireside Finishings
Walker Wood Mantel
Full Wood Mantel · Primed MDF
Fireside Finishings
Absolute Black Granite
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Bianco White Marble
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Blue Tundra Marble
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Beige Stone
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Steel Gray Granite
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Driftwood Marble
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Pauline Granite
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
New Venetian Granite
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Slate
Natural Stone Surround
Fireside Finishings
Crosby Wood Mantel Shelf
Wood Mantel Shelf · 48", 59", and 72" sizes
Fireside Finishings
Modern Concrete Non-Combustible Mantel
Concrete Shelf Mantel · Non-Combustible
Fireside Finishings
Traditional Concrete Non-Combustible Mantel
Concrete Shelf Mantel · Non-Combustible
Fireside Finishings
Ozark Wood Mantel Shelf
Wood Mantel Shelf
Fireside Finishings
Fillmore Wood Mantel Shelf
Wood Mantel Shelf
Fireside Finishings
Baxter Wood Mantel Shelf
Wood Mantel Shelf · 48", 59", and 72" sizes
SimpliFire
Boyd Cabinet Mantel (Modern Farmhouse)
Cabinet Mantel · for the Allusion Platinum 50
SimpliFire
Boyd Cabinet Mantel (Ready-to-Finish)
Cabinet Mantel · for the Allusion Platinum 50
Mount Vernon Mantels
Lincoln
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Williamsburg Arch 4
Full Mantel · Independence Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Harding
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Concord
Full Mantel · Fillmore Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Havenswood
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Kingston
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Lewisburg
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Llewellyn
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Marion
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
U.S. Grant
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Lewisburg Wide Leg
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Lincoln Wide Leg
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
US Grant Wide Leg
Full Mantel · American Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Providence Arch 2
Full Mantel · Independence Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Providence Straight 3
Full Mantel · Independence Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Williamsburg Straight 5
Full Mantel · Independence Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Braden
Full Mantel · MDF Builder Grade
Mount Vernon Mantels
Bronte
Full Mantel · MDF Builder Grade
Mount Vernon Mantels
Haley
Full Mantel · MDF Builder Grade
Mount Vernon Mantels
Philadelphia
Full Mantel · Fillmore Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Raleigh
Full Mantel · Fillmore Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Annapolis
Full Mantel · Fillmore Collection
Mount Vernon Mantels
Homestead Hammered Oak
Mantel Shelf · Homestead Mantel Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Boxford
Mantel Shelf · Designer Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Cressingham
Mantel Shelf · Designer Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Essex
Mantel Shelf · Designer Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Monarch
Mantel Shelf · Designer Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Newbury
Mantel Shelf · Designer Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Thacham
Mantel Shelf · Designer Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Victory
Mantel Shelf · Designer Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Homestead Chiseled Oak
Mantel Shelf · Homestead Mantel Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Custom Engraved Shelf
Mantel Shelf · Custom Engraved Shelves
Mount Vernon Mantels
Lewisburg Straight Cabinet
Fireplace Cabinet · Straight Cabinet
Mount Vernon Mantels
Providence Arch 5 Cabinet
Fireplace Cabinet · Straight Cabinet
Mount Vernon Mantels
Harding Straight Cabinet
Fireplace Cabinet · Straight Cabinet
Mount Vernon Mantels
Williamsburg Straight 3 Corner Cabinet
Fireplace Cabinet · Corner Cabinet
Mount Vernon Mantels
Williamsburg Straight 1 Corner Cabinet
Fireplace Cabinet · Corner Cabinet
Mount Vernon Mantels
Saint George Straight Corner Cabinet
Fireplace Cabinet · Corner Cabinet
No products match your filters
Try adjusting your search or clearing the filters.
MagraHearth pieces are crafted from lightweight, heat-safe materials, so they can sit closer to the fire than wood; the swatches under each card are the finishes it comes in—tap one to see it up close. Mount Vernon builds every mantel to your fireplace’s measurements, and its cabinets come in select red oak, stain-grade poplar, or paint grade.
Frame Your Fireplace With Style & Substance
Transform the Whole Fireplace Wall
Add character and warmth to your living space with a custom mantel or cabinet surround that perfectly complements your fireplace. At Hearths A’Fire, we offer handcrafted wood mantels, non-combustible alternatives, and furniture-quality cabinetry designed to match any style—from rustic farmhouse to clean-lined modern.
Whether you’re completing a brand-new fireplace or updating an existing one, our curated collection combines timeless design with modern safety standards to give your home the finishing touch it deserves.
Schedule Appointment
Here's How to Get Started
4 Simple Steps to a Finished Fireplace Wall
1
Pick Your Look
Browse the mantels and cabinets above and note the styles you like—wood, non-combustible concrete, or natural stone.
2
Visit Our Showroom
Visit our showroom to see mantels and finishes in person and meet our friendly team.
3
Book an In-Home Evaluation
Book an in-home evaluation with our experts to confirm the final details of your project.
4
Enjoy a Professional Installation
Enjoy a safe and professional installation—along with comprehensive service for years to come.
Our curated selection blends classic charm with modern craftsmanship, giving your fireplace the perfect finishing touch.
Schedule AppointmentIn Their Words
Real Reviews From Our Customers
Unedited, straight from Google.
4.5 68 Google reviews
“We purchased a propane fireplace from Hearths A'Fire and had little to no experience with installation or maintenance. The customer service here is exceptional. I cant say enough about a gentleman by the name of Brian. He has gone far above and beyond for me...”
Read the full review
We purchased a propane fireplace from Hearths A'Fire and had little to no experience with installation or maintenance. The customer service here is exceptional. I cant say enough about a gentleman by the name of Brian. He has gone far above and beyond for me in any time of need. He's about as professional and personable as anyone I've encountered and has truly shown he cares. He recently came with another very helpful gentleman by the name of Luke, even when their schedules are packed, to help me resolve a maintenance issue. Im truly thankful for the customer service I've received from these folks. Highly recommended!
“We just had a new Harmon pellet stove installed. The quality of the work was exceptional ! We are repeat customers of Jeff and wouldn’t go anywhere else. Highly recommend !”
“I needed a new igniter for my Harmon pellet stove. The team walked me through analyzing my situation, had the part on hand and now I’m ready for the winter. THANK YOU.”
“Very nice people....great service”
Showing all 4 reviews
The Oneonta Showroom
Visit Our Oneonta Showroom
With a 5,000 square foot showroom, 60+ displays, and over 30 years of experience, we know how to blend cozy charm with modern convenience. Visit our showroom to see your selected stove or fireplace and meet our friendly team.
Showroom Hours
- Monday–Friday
- 9:00am–5:30pm
- Saturday
- 9:00am–3:00pm
- Sunday
- Closed
Checking hours…
Common Questions
Common Questions About Fireplace Mantels
The questions we hear most on the showroom floor, answered plainly.
Schedule AppointmentShould I choose a wood or non-combustible mantel?
It comes down to clearances. A wood mantel needs safe distance from the firebox, while MagraHearth’s non-combustible mantels and surrounds are crafted from lightweight, heat-safe materials, allowing you to install them closer to the fire. Our in-house team confirms the clearances at your in-home evaluation.
Do you build custom sizes?
Yes. Mount Vernon Mantels builds each mantel to your fireplace’s measurements and can custom make a cabinet to fit almost any other fireplace unit, and several Fireside Finishings mantel shelves come in 48-, 59-, and 72-inch lengths. We measure your fireplace before anything is ordered.
Do you carry natural stone surrounds?
Yes. Fireside Finishings surrounds come in granite, marble, beige stone, and slate—Absolute Black Granite, Bianco White Marble, Steel Gray Granite, and more—so the face around the firebox matches the mantel above it.
Which fireplaces fit a cabinet?
Mount Vernon cabinets are built around direct-vent and vent-free fireplace units, for straight walls or corners, and the SimpliFire Boyd Cabinet Mantel is designed exclusively for the SimpliFire Allusion Platinum 50 electric fireplace. Tell us the model you have in mind and we’ll confirm the fit.
Who installs it?
We install what we sell. Whether you’re completing a brand-new fireplace or updating an existing one, our trained in-house team ensures safe, code-compliant installation with attention to detail.
We'd Love to Help You Too
Ready to Start Your Project?
See the mantels, cabinets, and finishes in person at our Oneonta showroom, then let our in-house team measure and install the one you love.